Why “Wild” is hotter than “50 Shades…”

I have a good marriage.  I don’t apologize for it, it is hard work which we both take very seriously.  I have no complaints about that area.  But after having been married for 15 years, I was fairly excited to hear about a new book called “50 Shades of Grey,” which one of my friends dubbed the the precise tome “guaranteed to take your sex life to the next level.”  Well, with an endorsement like that, I was intrigued.  Then the spots on the Today Show, Dr. Oz, SNL etc, etc… I had to read this book!  As luck would have it, I had reason to read because our planned book club books had been announced.  First up, 50 Shades.  Next, a book called “Wild” about a woman who hikes the Pacific Crest Trail.   I dove head first into 50 Shades.

Before I say what I am about to say, let me first admit that I have not read books two and three.  I don’t even remember their names.  Nor am I some elitist pontificater who doesn’t read any trash.  I did read all three Twilight books after all.  But, I am sorry.  I just don’t get it.  Yes, there is some nice juicy sex.  And I suppose it has earned the escapist term “mommy porn.”  But the writing is unforgivably poor and the story is a yawn.  Not to mention the fact that this book is set in the town where I reside and as my friend Tracy says, “nothing sexy happens here.”  And yet some of my favorite people have read the books and loved them, encouraging me to hang in there until the end when our fearless Christian Grey is exposed as a confused and previously abused guy who was really a good guy all along.  And who, despite his tortured past, falls in love with our heroine.  Bullshit.  And when your daughter comes home and says she met this AWESOME guy who is RICH and GORGEOUS and who just wants her to sign an itty bitty little contract saying that they need to sleep in seperate bedrooms and she needs to eat properly.   Oh, and he keeps telling her to not get attached to him.  And after all your conversations with your daughter about how you can’t fix a man and that when a person tells you who they are, believe them.  Well, after all that, you’re gonna tell her to grab a pen!  Sign up!  No, you are not.  I know, I know, I need to lighten up!  I need to get swept into the story and simply enjoy it!  I am not capable of suspending reality to that extent.  But you go right ahead if you want.

Yesterday, I went on a hike with my husband.  It was a virtual tidal wave to the senses.  We walked from a dark and cool overhang of trees onto a brilliant horizon dotted with a array of brightly colored wildflowers.  We talked, but not too much.  The noises of birds tweeting, creeks bubbling and twigs snapping beneath our feet was enough background for our walk.  At points, we paused to sample some delicious, bursting huckleberries.  Hundreds lined our way.  The sweet smell of evergreen!  And that dusty grey sheen on your skin and clothes, evidence of a day well spent. The noise of our own busy lives fell away and I remembered why I had fallen in love with him in the first place.  (For those of you currently unattached,  I also found as a single gal that a good walk is a great way to weed out the guys who can’t carry on a conversation or appreciate beauty).   Nothing is as tantalizing as walking behind someone, imagining ways you could pull off to the side of the trail, the thrill of knowing someone could pass by at any moment and the endless possibilities that await you at trail’s end.  Let’s face it folks, nature is hot.

I read “Wild” after I finished “50 Shades.”  Both sit atop the best seller lists, the yin and yang of suburban moms everywhere.    Now, which book title would you have picked for the mommy porn by the way?  50 Shades of Grey sounds like a memoir of a funeral parlor.  I digress.  Wild’s author, Cheryl Strayed , is by her own account a very sexual person.  She uses sex to express herself and to process her emotions, albeit not always in a very healthy way.  But her account of her pilgrimage from “lost to found” is visceral and deep nonetheless and she takes us to places in our hearts and souls that are most profound.  Well, what does that have to do with fucking, you ask?   Alot, as it turns out.  A very favorable NY Times book review calls the book “loose and sexy and dark” and one of the critiques on Strayed’s website says it “reminds us of what it feels to be fully alive.”  Isn’t that what sex is really about?  Feeling alive?  She recounts her adventures in such a lucid  and fun way that you want to strap on a backpack and get your own adventure on.  The spirit of the book is so free and the landscape so primitive that it’s impossible to escape the desire to undertake your own journey.   And as many of you I am sure can attest, outdoor sex has it’s own S&M elements, if you count the scratching of rocks and trees upon your ass or other naked parts.

In an on air discussion by Sirius XM of why moms liked 50 Shades so much, the answers tended toward the following:  women liked being “taken care of” by their man without being asked, they wanted to be both adored and ravaged, they were tired of being the one to make everyone else happy.  I hear them!  But this book was written by a woman who knows these things too.  (Author EL James is brilliant if not the best storyteller).  And if Christian Grey had been poor and ugly, would you still want him?  Maybe if you really want these things, just make a photocopy of the page in the book and give it to your man.  Oh wait a minute, that’s still asking him.  Here’s the thing.  Men really do want to make you squeal.  It’s okay to ask them.  Isn’t that what you are doing by reading the book in front of him anyway?

If 50 Shades gets you hot, have fun!  I applaud you and I am happy for you that you’re getting it.  But place getting “Wild” on your to do list, too.  Maybe try a pair of hiking boots instead of a pair of handcuffs.  And please tell me why I should or should not continue reading the series.

“There were so many amazing things in this world.   They opened up inside me like a river.”  Cheryl Strayed, “Wild.”

Now that’s hot.


13 comments on “Why “Wild” is hotter than “50 Shades…”

  1. Mari Stephenson says:

    I think that the reason “50 Shades…..” is getting so much attention is that it is the first time (I’m not sure what brought this about) that many women have been comfortable, or felt they had permission to read porn. You are right. It is poorly written and I actually go so bored by the end that I didn’t finish it.
    There is a lot of well written erotica for women. I hope that maybe “50 Shades….” will encourage women to seek it out.

    Men get porn….they know how to use it. It is a little more foreign to women. Happy hunting ladies.

    • suburbotypes says:

      Excellent point. Maybe they should reprint the book and BOLD the sex scenes in the book so everyone can skip to there. Just like they fast forward the DVD on porn flicks.

  2. This post hits very close to me and my life. I think can relate to the author of “Wild” in terms of being a sexual women who uses sex to express emotions and for pleasure, but as you said, maybe not in the healthiest way. I also have always been driven to write well… sensual material. Since I was 12 years old I kid you not. I also have taken several backpacking trips, alone, never camping, I stay in hostels, but abroad or in the US, and during said trips I can be…sexually expressive (in a town, the wine country of Argentina, Mendoza, I slept in 4 different hostels, 1 was the one I’d booked for myself, the 3 others, with 3 different guys, in the 4 nights I was there…then hopped a bus to Buenos Aires and slept with my hosts roommate…yah, i was on a spree!)

    Anyhow, after I was recently fired and living in San Francisco I received allll sorts of advice, you should start writing again, start a blog, travel and write a blog about that, the guy i was dating suggesting I do the Pacific Crest Trail, on my own (we were in the process of parting ways ourselves) and blog about that. As the same time 50 Shades of Grey had hit the masses. Wild sounds like what my blog could have become. I did a serial ” Sex Hiatus: an experiment”. Not as interesting or insightful, but I will DEFINITELY check out the book, it sounds so close to me and I need that right now as I’m feeling quite lonely – especially since i began that Sex Hiatus! (which by the way you can find here if interested:) http://iamanafterschoolspecial.wordpress.com/archived-features/

    Thanks for sharing!

  3. twillett says:

    I admit it I fit the mold of the reader who should like 50 shades. However, I couldn’t do it, I could not find any allure to his arrogance and could not dedicate any of my time to something that made me more annoyed with each page turned. I am on my way to pick up “Wild” as I have not really contemplated pulling my husband off the path to have my way with him. Maybe it has something to do with the small children that are always with us. But I am going to read the book and Hike with my husband and no kids and see what happens. Thanks 🙂

  4. Heather says:

    Thrilled to have a new book suggestion! Will go and get “Wild” today! Your asking for a reason to either finish “50 shades” or call it quits. There definitely is one reason to keep reading. But before I tell you that reason,let me fill you in. I am an series reader. Most books are too short for me, I finish them craving more, more depth, more character development, more storyline. I’ve read the entire “Outlander” series by Diana Gabaldon twice. Now those books hit the spot for me. Love, action, adventure, and tasteful believable sex. The “50 Shades” books had me excited when I first heard about them so I dove right in and finished all three in about a week and a half. But honestly I read them quickly not because I was so engrossed, I was trying to get to the “good stuff”. The part where these two people strip themselves down to expose their bare souls. There is one scene in the 2nd book that came close. My heart actually ached. That scene is what encouraged me to keep going. Then it never happened again. Complete disappointment. I can actually see these books mirroring a porn. Like bow-chica-wow-wow bad acting, incomplete storyline, no real depth of relationship. So if you wish, read book two until you get to that point in the story where Christian comes close to redeeming this series (you’ll know it when your there) then you may stop. Because it’s like something that builds with intensity, feels so good you look so forward to the release, then disappointingly your release never happens….. Like a sneeze.

    • suburbotypes says:

      Sorry Wild is not a series but it is well worth your time. I know what you mean about character development, and I do love reading series books as well. Will have to check out Outlander series. I love “bow chica wow wow,” that’s awesome. I haven’t heard a good reason yet to finish the series. Thanks so much for your insights!

  5. I read all 3, but did not find them interesting at all. It was a struggle to finish them! I’m with Mari, on this though, “porn for women” is not as accepting or easy to find I guess and it looks like it should be. I just found it funny, that if all the men in Clark County here, knew years ago that all of their wives would be beyond turned on with bondage! WOW!!… Clark County WOULD be a bit more sexy!

  6. loseitbig says:

    I am just glad I have a nook. No one can really see that I am trying to read 50 Shades (the nook doesn’t show the cover). I am going to look at Wild to see what that one is all about. Thanks for the heads up.

  7. Cindy says:

    I could not compel myself to pick up 50 Shades, not even download it secretly on my kindle. I think I made this decision when my 25 year old hair dresser said she found the writing amateur.

    Jeanne, agree with everything you said about “Wild”–it is a sexy book, but subtle sexy, which makes it sexier. (Okay, the sex on the rocks was not subtle, but the rest was. I don’t think this is a big plot spoiler to say this.) I have urged everyone to read this. Yes, it made me want to go for a long hike. It also made see hitchhikers differently, and maybe I should give one a lift someday.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s